Politics

Who was Edward G. Calhoun?

Four of the five African-American men named in 1883 as Republican Party officers or candidates were familiar, long-term Wilson County residents. The fifth, however, is unfamiliar. Who was Edward G. Calhoun?

The scant record reveals that Calhoun may have been born in North Carolina, but came back into the state in the 1870s as a freedman from Bullock County, Alabama. We have some evidence of his political activity in Wilson County in the 1880s, then he disappears from the record.

Calhoun is first found as Ned Calhoun in a 1867 Bullock County voter registration ledger.

On 28 July 1868, freedman Ned Calhoun married freedwoman Rachel Shepherd in Bullock County.

In the 1870 census of Greenwood township, Bullock County, Alabama: Ned Calhoun, 23, farm laborer; wife Rachael, 21; farm laborer; and daughter Rebecca, 1.

By the mid-1870s, the Calhouns were in Wilson County.

In the 1880 census of Saratoga township, Wilson County: laborer Ned Calhoon, 35; wife Rachel, 27; and children Henry G., 6, Elexander, 4, James M., 2, and Sarah A.L., 8 months. Ned reported that he and his parents were born in North Carolina. Rachel reported that she was born in South Carolina to North Carolina-born parents.

A notice in the 19 October 1881 Wilmington Morning Star advised that E.G. Calhoun was among residents with letters waiting at the post office. Is this the same man?

In 1882, E.G. Calhoun was elected secretary of the Wilson County Republican Party and in April 1883 submitted a letter to an African-American newspaper in Raleigh.

The Banner-Enterprise (Raleigh, N.C.), 19 April 1883. 

This is our last glimpse of Calhoun in real time.

By 1900, his widow Rachel had remarried and been widowed again and lived in south Georgia with their younger children.

In the 1900 census of Douglas district, Coffee County, Georgia: widow Rachel Towns, 40, and children Henry C., 26, James C., 22, Marcellus, 18, Walter, 13, Bessie, 11, and Ada, 8. Rachel reported that she was born in Alabama to South Carolina-born parents; Henry and James were reported as born in Alabama; Marcellus, Walter, and Bessie, in North Carolina; and Ada in Georgia.

On 22 February 1903, Henry Calhoun married Lessie Sturdivant in Coffee County, Georgia. On 3 May 1903, Marcellus Calhoun married Annie Dixon in Coffee County.

In the 1910 census of Precinct 9, Hernando County, Florida: Walter Calhoun, 23, turpentine laborer, born in N.C., and wife Cora, 17.

In the 1910 census of Precinct 9, Hernando County, Florida: J.M. Calhoun, 33, turpentine laborer, born in North Carolina; wife Elizabeth, 30; and children Bertha, 6, and Willie G., 3.

In the 1910 census of Coffee County, Georgia: Marcellus Calhoun, 28, turpentine laborer, born in N.C.; wife Anna, 21; and children Rozel, 6, Esther, 3, and Lula, 17 months.

In 1918, James Monroe Calhoun registered for the World War I draft in Hernando County, Florida. Per his registration card, he was born 7 August 1877; lived in Centralia, Hernando County; worked as a laborer for L.P. Petteway; and his nearest relative was Elizabeth Calhoun.

In the 1923 Waycross, Georgia, city directory: Calhoun Walter D (Cora) driver h 631 Pittman

In the 1930 census of Brooks County, Georgia: Walter Calhoun, 53, naval stores laborer; wife Pearl, 29; and children Robert, 7, Walter D., 4, Lorena, 2, and Bessie, 3 months.

In the 1930 census of Brooksville, Hernando County, Florida: on A.C.L. Street, renting for $6/month, lumberyard laborer James M. Calhoun, 52; wife Elizabeth, 50; children Willie G., 23, hauling blocks at veneer mill, and Ruby O., 18; and granddaughter Mary L., 11.

In the 1935 state census of Hernando County, Florida: inside Brooksville town limits,  Jim Calhoun, 57, born in N.C., renter, crosstie cutter; wife Elizabeth, 55, born in N.C.; and granddaughter Mary Lee, 16, born in Florida, cook.

James Monroe Calhoun died 20 September 1937 in Brooksville, Hernando County, Florida. Per his death certificate, he was born 7 August 1877 in Wilson County, North Carolina, to Edward G. Calhoun. He was married to Elizabeth Calhoun; worked as a laborer; and died of laceration to his left leg sustained while cutting a tree.

In 1940, Herbert Lee Calhoun registered for the World War II draft in Waycross, Ware County, Georgia. Per his registration card, he was born 20 June 1913 in Orlando, Florida; lived at 719 Daniel Street, Waycross; his contact was father Walter David Calhoun, 911 Daniel Street; he worked at the Bund Building; and he had a defective left eye.

Alabama, U.S., County Marriage Records 1805-1967, http://www.ancestry.com.

Lane Street Project: the response to the August 5 request, part 1.

Today I received the City’s response to my August 5 public records request for all documents reflecting any discussion of or action taken concerning Vick Cemetery since 1 September 2023. It contained 270 documents, most of which appear to be multiple duplicates of the same record. As always, I will share with you those records that raised my eyebrow.

Part 1: City Manager Grant Goings’ gratuitous slaps at me, Lane Street Project, and all the volunteers who work so hard to reclaim Odd Fellows Cemetery. “Look! Vick and Rest Haven look better than Odd Fellows!” is a strange flex. My annotations, per usual, in red.

 

 

 

[Let me know if you want “receipts” for my annotations. I’ve got a whole blog-full.]

Ex-Senator Person speaks out for Samuel H. Vick.

The Washington Bee, 14 March 1903.

——

As Samuel H. Vick faced ouster from his postmaster position, William Lee Person wrote a scathing letter to the Washington Bee defending Vick’s honor, chastising United States Congressman Henry P. Cheatham, and excoriating Lily White Jeter C. Pritchard.

Lee Person’s career had multiple parallels to Vick’s, having incorporated several fraternal lodges and founded a bank and a tuberculosis sanatorium. Person also served as Rocky Mount’s postmaster for several years before being elected to represent his district in the North Carolina state senate. There, he fought unsuccessfully to enact laws against lynching and to prevent discrimination in passenger accommodations.

Lane Street Project: city memos re Vick Cemetery, 1994-1995.

These documents concerning the City’s discussion of Vick Cemetery in the half-decade prior to its clearing of the space came to me not via my own public records request, but that of a media outlet. I will publish the memos, with comments, in two parts — the first from 1989-1991, and the second from 1994-1995.

On 2 June 1994, spirited public discussion broke out at a council meeting concerning the cost of Vick Cemetery restoration. This appeared to spark a couple of behind-scenes memoranda.

On 12 July 1994, Deputy City Manager Charles W. Pittman wrote City Manager Edward A. Wyatt to report his discussions with James A. Hill about cleaning up Vick Cemetery. Though Hill indicated he would honor his 1989 proposal, Pittman advised the job would have to be bid out.

The next day, Wyatt wrote the mayor [C. Bruce Rose] and council to advise that the project, done right, would be expensive. “In order to comply with General Statute requirements, extreme care must be taken to improve a cemetery, which will require a lot of careful work to be done. I can assure you that the work will certainly be done in an appropriate manner. It will be administered by Charles Pittman and the Public Works department.” With such firm early avowals, how did things go so terribly wrong?

At the 25 July 1994 meeting, council members resumed the debate. Steve Stancil said he would like to restore the cemetery, but perhaps the City could limit expenditures to $50,000 that year and use unemployed people for manual labor the first year. A.P. Coleman drily responded that “it would have cost the City a lot more money if the City had acknowledged the fact that it owned the cemetery and had maintained it all these years; and that it was a disgrace to not have restored it sooner.”

As we have noted a zillion times, the City’s project description, “Restoration and Improvement S.H. Vick Cemetery Lane St. Wilson, N.C.,” which issued later that year, included these provisions:

  • in Section 4A,  “All existing graves whether marked by a grave marker or not shall be identified and located so as to be able to be re-located after completion of the work. A detailed survey may be needed in order to ensure that graves are marked in the correct location after completion of the work. A drawing showing all graves shall be prepared for future reference. All existing tombstones shall be removed, labeled, and stored until after all work is completed.”
  • and in Section 4E: “All graves identified and located prior to construction shall be re-located and marked. Graves shall be marked in one of two ways: (1) Tombstones removed from graves prior to construction shall be reset at the proper grave locations. (2) Any unmarked graves which were located shall be marked by means of a small metal marker as typically used in cemeteries. A map showing the locations of all graves shall be furnished to the City of Wilson.”

On 3 November 1994, Council voted to award the project to PLT Construction, which began work quickly. However, for reasons yet unexplained, the wheels quickly fell off the original plan.

On 7 April 1995, Charles Pittman sent Ed Wyatt a memo that referred to “much discussion” having “taken place regarding addressing the Vick Cemetery with a central monument versus the individual designated markers.” In the long term, he noted, savings “could be quite [sic] significant when considering the time required to cut grass in an open area versus cutting around individual markers in the cemetery. Cutting around markers requires a lot of manual labor.”

The third paragraph of Pittman’s memo is the gut-punch: “From a public perspective, there has been some concern to the reception of the idea by those who have loved ones buried there.” Thus, contrary to the assertion of current councilmember James Johnson, who was already on council back then, the City was aware that permanently removing individual markers was a touchy proposition. After noting that a public meeting had been set to give family members “a chance to comment on the proposed changes,” Wyatt added, “I have already received one call from Mr. Robbins expressing concern about the graves of four of his family members.”

The public meeting went forward at B.O. Barnes Elementary School on April 24. Public records requests made by multiple parties have yielded no notes, minutes, memos, or other documents showing what occurred at the meeting or for three and a half months after.

Wilson Daily Times, 22 April 1995.

However, on 10 August 1995, Ed Wyatt reached out to Rose and council again. “Staff with other interested persons” — who? — had been working with Joyner’s Memorials on the central monument, “the most feasible way to approach this project.” With a proposed fence (around the cemetery? the monument?) eliminated from the plan, the project would come in at $28,000. “It is the intent not to reset the original monuments allowing maintenance to be held to a minimum.”

On August 18, Wyatt sent a slightly modified version of the same memo.

Councilman Steve Stancil’s acerbic response came four days later. He opposed the central monument, calling it “an unnecessary expense” and questioning “how long this investment would remain intact without destruction.” In his view, cleaning up the cemetery had “fulfilled [the City’s] commitment,” and, with an eye on retaining his council seat, recommended that Wyatt “bring this topic up to Council for another vote after the November election.” Stancil wrapped his memo with finger-wagging: “Ed, it continues to bother me how you seem to justify spending additional money on a project just because the project is ‘in the scope of the budget previously approved.’ I am certain this particular money could be spent on something much more useful for the living.” A brief pencilled scrawl shows that Wyatt passed the memo on to Deputy City Manager Charles Pittman.

Seven days later, the Wilson Daily Times announced the city’s plan to erect a single monument in the middle of Vick Cemetery. “It would help, from a maintenance standpoint, to have one big monument,” City Manager Ed Wyatt said, citing the cost and time required to mow around headstones. Wyatt stated that the City’s public works department would store Vick’s intact headstones. Wyatt also stated that “the general concept of a central monument was first mentioned at a neighborhood meeting.”

We know from the April 7 memo above that this was not true. That memo, drafted two weeks before the “neighborhood meeting” at Barnes school, makes clear that the central monument “concept” had already been discussed at length — and the City knew it was controversial. Nonetheless, folks will try to have you believe that the descendant community, or one or two representative Black people, wholeheartedly endorsed a plan to rip their family members’ headstones out of the ground and replace them with a generic granite obelisk. We rebuke the notion. And where are the headstones???